Opinions Please!

I'm still trying to catch up on my scrapbooking! I decided to do some digital pages of the boys' birthday last year. Problem is I made pages from two different kits and now I can't decide which one to print. The layout and pictures of the pages will be the same, just the paper and embellishments are different. Please tell me your feelings and help me decide which paper/embellishment combo you like best!

1.


2.

I am going to print one two-page spread for each boy. The Kits are from http://www.designerdigitals.com/ Thanks for your help!